It came up on calls again this week: “We can just about get to 20% down. Should we stretch to get there so we don’t pay mortgage insurance?”
It’s a fair question, and most people have already decided the answer is yes. Twenty percent down has become the finish line. Hit it, and you’ve “won.”
But avoiding mortgage insurance is only half the math. The other half is what that money would be doing if it weren’t sitting in your house. Sometimes stretching to 20% is the right call. Sometimes it’s the expensive one.
What mortgage insurance actually costs
If you put less than 20% down, your mortgage has to be insured against default. The premium isn’t small, and two details catch people off guard:
- It’s charged on the whole mortgage, not just the gap below 20%. At 10% down, the premium is 3.10% of the loan. At 15% to 19.99% down, it’s 2.80%.
- In Ontario, you also pay 8% PST on the premium, in cash, at closing. The premium itself gets added to your mortgage, but the tax can’t be.
On a $900,000 purchase with 10% down, that’s a premium of about $25,100 added to the mortgage, plus about $2,000 in PST on closing day.
That’s the number everyone focuses on. Here’s the one they miss.
Insured mortgages get better rates
Because the lender is protected, insured mortgages usually come with a lower rate than conventional ones (20% or more down). This week, the best 5-year fixed I’m seeing for an insured mortgage is about 0.35% lower than the best conventional rate.
That doesn’t erase the premium. But it chips away at it every month.
The real question: what would that money be doing?
Here’s how I ran it. Two buyers, same $900,000 home, and each has the same $180,000 saved.
- Buyer A puts the full 20% down.
- Buyer B puts 10% down, pays the PST, and invests the remaining $88,000 in a TFSA. Buyer B’s mortgage payment is about $500 a month higher, and that difference comes out of the investment account every month.
After 10 years, who’s ahead? It depends on what the investments earn:
| Down payment | Cash kept | 4% return | 6% return | 8% return | Breakeven return |
| 10% | $88,000 | −$22,500 | −$3,200 | +$20,200 | 6.3% |
| 15% | $43,000 | −$12,600 | −$2,800 | +$9,000 | 6.5% |
| 19% | $7,000 | −$7,900 | −$6,000 | −$3,700 | 10.6% |
Net worth compared with the buyer who put 20% down, after 10 years. Negative means the 20% buyer is ahead.
Over a shorter window, the picture changes. After 5 years, the 20% buyer is still ahead in every case, even at 8% returns. At 10% down, you’d need about 9% a year just to break even over five years.
So the takeaway isn’t “always put less down.” It’s that time and discipline decide it. If you’ll leave the money invested for a decade and genuinely not touch it, keeping 10% to 15% down and investing the rest can come out ahead. If you’ll dip into it, or you’re likely to move or refinance in a few years, 20% usually wins.
How I ran the numbers: 5-year fixed rates of 4.74% (insured) and 5.09% (conventional), 25-year amortization, tax-free returns in a TFSA, and the same 0.35% rate gap at renewal. Rates change, the gap at renewal may not be the same, and investment returns aren’t guaranteed. This is an illustration, not a forecast.
Cash after closing is worth more than people think
This is the part the spreadsheet doesn’t capture, and in my experience it matters most.
Buying a home doesn’t end on closing day. There’s furniture, window coverings, the appliance that dies in month three, and the renovation you’ve already planned. If stretching to 20% leaves you with nothing in the bank, those costs land on a credit card at 20% or more, or a line of credit at prime plus. That wipes out any rate “savings” from the bigger down payment very quickly.
And once your money is in the house, it’s hard to get back. The only ways out are a refinance or a home equity line of credit, and both mean qualifying all over again, at whatever rates are on offer at the time.
A few things to keep in mind:
- Lenders want to see closing costs covered. Plan on about 1.5% of the purchase price in addition to your down payment.
- An emergency fund is a real asset. Three to six months of expenses in the bank is worth more to most first-year homeowners than a slightly smaller mortgage.
- Planned renovations belong in the budget now, not after closing.
When closing the gap does make sense
There’s one situation where I’ll almost always say “get to 20%”: when you’re already close.
At 15% to 19.99% down, you’re still paying a 2.80% premium on the entire mortgage, but you’re only keeping a small amount of cash. Look at the 19% row in the table: even at an 8% return over 10 years, you’re still behind. The premium is just too big for the cash you keep.
If that’s you, here are a few ways to close the gap:
- A gift from family. Immediate family can gift part of the down payment. They’ll sign a gift letter, and we’ll need to see the funds land in your account.
- Your FHSA. Up to $8,000 a year, and it comes out tax-free when you buy. If you haven’t opened one, the December 31 deadline matters more than most people think.
- The RRSP Home Buyers’ Plan. First-time buyers can withdraw up to $60,000 from their RRSP and repay it over 15 years.
How I’d decide
Three questions get you most of the way there:
- How long will you leave the money alone? Ten years or more favours investing. Under five years favours a bigger down payment.
- What do you need cash for in the first year? Furniture, renovations, an emergency fund. Set that aside first, then decide on the down payment with what’s left.
- How close are you to 20%? Within a few percent, closing the gap usually wins. Further away, the decision is a lot more open.
There’s no single right number. “20% or nothing” is a rule of thumb, and it ignores what your money could be doing and what you’ll actually need once you move in.
This Week’s Market Update
Mortgage shoppers caught a break this week. Canada’s inflation held at 3.1% in October, a touch below what was expected. Stocks sold off and oil dropped more than 3%, and that pushed bond yields, which fixed rates follow, down a little.
But it was one good day, not a turnaround. Markets still see a Bank of Canada hike on December 9 as a coin flip, nearly certain by January, with about four more hikes priced in for this cycle.
Buying, renewing or on a variable rate? Now is the time to get a plan in place.
Watch this week’s rate update →
If you’d like me to run your purchase both ways, with your price, your savings and what you’ve got planned after you move in, I’m happy to walk you through it.
Overview
Subscribe to begin.
Join 7.5k+ subscribers and get tips, strategies and market updates every other Thursday morning.






